Is it time to turn my back on Labour and give the Lib-Dems a chance? #GE2010

 Have a  look at the list of manifesto pledges below…

  • Creating a fairer tax system to take more low-paid workers out of tax 
  • Holding a comprehensive defense review – including scrapping Eurofighter and Trident 
  • Restoring the Index-link to pensions, immediately 
  • Breaking up banks to improve security of the retail banking sector 
  • Major investment in green industries 
  • £2.5billion scheme to improve funding per pupil in the most deprived areas 
  • Reducing testing and giving teachers more freedom in the classroom 
  • A Higher Education system that is free of tuition fees
  • The right to request flexible working for all 
  • Joint parental leave of up to 18months for all new parents 
  • Decreasing our dependency on nuclear power 
  • Stronger european co-operation on trade, crime, climate-change and defense
  • A presumption against short-term sentencing
  • Treating drug addicts as ill rather than criminals 
  • Making a positive case for inward migration within the context of a fairer immigration policy
  • Scrapping ID cards and biometric passports 
  • Reduce maximum pre-charge detention to 14days 
  • Remove innocent people from DNA register 
  • Introduce a Freedom Bill to protect against intrusion from CCTV
  • Introduction of a fully elected House of Lords 
  • Voting for Over 16s 
  • Fixed-term parliaments 
  • Introduction of proportional representation 
What party would you think you were voting for? OK, so I admit the final point makes it more obviously Liberal Democrat, but before then? Be honest now, it sounded a lot more like a traditional Labour party manifesto  didn’t it?  Certainly more than anything I have heard come from the Labour party in recent times.
Through the TV debates the Lib Dems have really found their voice and become a party who feel and look like their time has come. Increasing disenchantment with the two main parties, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the expenses scandal have combined to undermine trust in both politicians and the current political system as a whole. This has led to people searching around for alternatives, and the Lib Dems have become the prime beneficiary of this.
For me it is more than this, of all the manifestos, and I have read them, they are the ones who most convincingly talk about fairness. Fairness within tax, fairness in educational opportunity, fairness in immigration and, of course fairness within the electoral system. They are also the only party who have put in detailed costs against their spending commitments (albeit  taken with a large pinch of salt).
On a more personal level I have been impressed with Nick Clegg and his party’s decision not to duck the difficult conversations – to be boldly pro-european and to argue the positives of immigration are but two areas where it would be easier to capitulate to the print-press but instead they have taken the time to argue their case – seemingly with some success.
As a member of the Labour party – voting decisions should be a relative breeze for me, but this time I find myself scrabbling round for reasons to vote Labour whilst all the time a voice in my head suggests otherwise. Being loyal to a party is important, but  what if you come to feel that another party better represents your values? Perhaps it is time to change?
At the moment, the current electoral system means that, in my constituency, it is likely to be a straight battle between Labour and the Tories, in theory delaying any voting angst I might have for future campaigns. But then again, the Lib-Dems were only 10 points or so behind last time and, as we know, a lot has happened since then and it is conceivable that they might be in the mix this time around. Particularly when you take into account the sitting Labour MP, Ann Keen is very unpopular after getting caught up in the expenses debacle.
So, 10 days to go and, for the first time in my life I am unsure as to who to vote for… a Labour party  that has done a mostly good job over the last 13 years ? Or a Lib-Dem party that feels more in tune with ideals around fairness and, well, liberalism. I’ll keep blogging as I make up my mind – I promise you’ll be the first to know!


  1. Full disclosure: I am a LibDem supporter – but not intesely partisan; if Labour pledged that manifesto tomorrow, I’d probably vote for them (assuming I could brush aside my concern as to the massive u-turns on issues such as Trident etc).

    I don’t blame you for being attached to a political party – to belong is a nice feeling. But I believe that you should never let partisan loyalty cloud your judgement: if your chosen political party is not the party that stands up for your values, perhaps you have chosen poorly! 😛

    So yes, I would implore you to vote Liberal Democrat. Not because I’m a party activist that blindly tells everyone to vote LibDem – I am not and I don’t, because asking non-liberals to vote LibDem would only lead to massive disappointment when such a government arrives and does not fulfill their non-liberal desires.

    Instead, I would suggest you vote Liberal Democrat for a very simple reason – they are the party you are currently most in agreement with. If you agree with a manifesto, vote for it! Don’t put party above country – do what you think is right for Britain, not for the fortunes of the Labour Party, because ultimately political parties should be a mechanism for empowering ideology, not an ideology unto themselves that people slavishly adhere to.

    Also, I’d say that the manifesto above looks like a traditional Liberal Democrat, not Labour, manifesto. Radical constitutional reform, massive fiscal policy overhaul, green economics, civil liberties and general liberalism have always been LibDem traits first and foremost. Labour share some of those traits, sure, but not all – and most only to a lesser degree. I love the compassionate principles of Labour too – but the LibDems are the ones raising the tax threshold for the poorest while taxing mansions.

    Labour are not radicals. They want to use the system to help the poor. That’s not a bad aim, in and of itself. But the Liberal Democrats will replace the system wholesale so that it works for the poor in the first place. And that, to me, is the kind of ideology I can vote for.

    TL;DR? Vote for the party that agrees with you. If you change your mind on that manifesto and decide you hate it, then I’d tell you to vote Labour. But seeing as you like these policies, you might as well vote for them, and perhaps one day New New Labour will get the message and embrace a liberal strain!

    Hope this helps you with you decision… and that I didn’t come across as a frothing-at-the-mouth-LibDem! 😛

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s